Comfort food is a welcome treat any time of year, but cooler temperatures make gooey classics like grilled cheese sandwiches even more satisfying. There’s something about that idyllic combination of buttery grilled bread and luscious, melty goodness that makes grilled cheese an irreplaceable favorite. From popular New York City chains to independent eateries, these spots make some of the best grilled cheese sandwiches in NYC.
These are some of the best grilled cheese sandwiches in NYC.
Truffle Melt at Melt Shop, Multiple Locations
Melt Shop is a tried and true grilled cheese favorite in NYC, and – personally – I’ll never stop raving about their Truffle Melt. The country white bread, melted muenster, peppery arugula, and decadent truffle oil all combine to make the perfect sandwich.
French Onion Soup Grilled Cheese Sandwich at Mother’s Ruin, 18 Spring St
For a tasty fusion of two classic dishes, stop into Mother’s Ruin in Nolita. Their savory French onion soup-inspired grilled cheese with gruyere, cheddar, Romano, and caramelized onions will surely sate your craving.
Grilled Cheese on Pullman Loaf at Wilfie & Nell, 228 W 4th St
If you’re a culinary minimalist who prefers a simpler approach to the classic sandwich, then you must try the grilled cheese sandwich on pullman loaf at Wilfie & Nell. Made with gouda and served with pickles and whole grain mustard on the side, locals love this bar’s “unfussy” approach to grilled cheese.
Murray’s Melt at Murray’s Cheese, 254 Bleecker St
Murray’s Cheese is a Greenwich Village icon, and patrons can stop into their flagship store for more than just an incredible variety of meats and cheeses. Pull up a seat at the counter and order the Murray’s Melt – a must-try grilled cheese sandwich with a secret blend of cheeses that has yet to be duplicated.
Crispy Goat at Cheese Grille NYC, 188 Allen St
As specialists in all things cheesy, Cheese Grille NYC offers a delicious lineup of grilled cheese sandwiches. Get the perfect trifecta of creaminess, fattiness, and freshness with the Crispy Goat. It’s a melted masterpiece of chèvre, goat gouda, applewood bacon, and avocado on multigrain bread.
NY State Cheddar Grilled Cheese at Earl’s Beer and Cheese, 1259 Park Ave
Care to try a different take on grilled cheese? Head uptown to Earl’s Beer and Cheese, where this hole-on-the-wall establishment serves up a NY State Cheddar Grilled Cheese with pork belly, kimchi, and a fried egg on sourdough.
The Famous Doughnut Grilled Cheese at Clinton Hall, 90 Washington St
The Famous Doughnut Grilled Cheese at Clinton Hall isn’t for the faint of heart; but for serious grilled cheese fans, it’s a definite must-try. This monstrous creation consists of a fresh-glazed doughnut stuffed with mozzarella cheese, bacon, and jalapeños – and it’s served hanging over a steaming bowl of tomato soup.
What are your picks for the best grilled cheese sandwiches in NYC? Let us know in the comments.